Loading page...
Strategy
Good to Great
by Jim Collins
Essential Reading for Scale-Up Leaders
A comprehensive review with actionable insights, key takeaways, and practical frameworks for scaling your business.
Why This Book Matters for Scale-Up Leaders
Scaling a company often brings rapid success, but sustaining that success over decades is much harder. Many companies achieve profitability, grow quickly, and even dominate in their early stages, only to stall or decline when faced with new challenges. Jim Collins set out to understand why.
In Good to Great, Collins and his research team conducted one of the most comprehensive business studies ever published. They examined thousands of companies and narrowed the field to eleven that made the leap from good to great, defined as moving from average performance to sustained market-beating performance over a period of at least fifteen years. These companies were compared with peers in the same industries that failed to make the leap. The contrasts revealed a set of consistent patterns that explained enduring greatness.
For scale-up leaders, the book’s insights are valuable because hypergrowth can mask underlying weaknesses. It is easy to confuse speed with sustainability. Good to Great reminds leaders that greatness is not built on flashy moves or one-off successes. It is built on discipline, clarity, and leadership that outlasts any single person or moment.
In Good to Great, Collins and his research team conducted one of the most comprehensive business studies ever published. They examined thousands of companies and narrowed the field to eleven that made the leap from good to great, defined as moving from average performance to sustained market-beating performance over a period of at least fifteen years. These companies were compared with peers in the same industries that failed to make the leap. The contrasts revealed a set of consistent patterns that explained enduring greatness.
For scale-up leaders, the book’s insights are valuable because hypergrowth can mask underlying weaknesses. It is easy to confuse speed with sustainability. Good to Great reminds leaders that greatness is not built on flashy moves or one-off successes. It is built on discipline, clarity, and leadership that outlasts any single person or moment.
Key Insights
Level 5 Leadership
Collins discovered that great companies were led by what he calls Level 5 leaders. These leaders are not celebrity CEOs. They are often quiet, humble, and modest. But beneath this humility is an almost ruthless determination to do whatever it takes to make the company succeed. They focus their ambition on the organisation rather than on personal fame. Darwin Smith of Kimberly-Clark is one of Collins’ examples. He transformed the company by exiting traditional paper products and investing in consumer paper goods, a bold and unpopular move that proved transformative.
First Who, Then What
Great leaders do not begin with strategy. They begin with people. Collins found that the most successful companies focused first on getting the right people on the bus and the wrong people off the bus before deciding where to drive it. The reasoning is simple. With the right team, you can adapt to any strategy or market shift. With the wrong team, no strategy will save you.
Confront the Brutal Facts
Companies that became great built cultures where it was safe to face reality. They were not trapped by false optimism or denial. They looked directly at problems, weaknesses, and risks and dealt with them honestly. Collins describes this as the Stockdale Paradox, named after Admiral Jim Stockdale who survived years of captivity during the Vietnam War by combining unwavering faith in eventual success with the ability to confront brutal facts in the present.
The Hedgehog Concept
The Hedgehog Concept is one of Collins’ most enduring ideas. Great companies simplify their strategy to a single organising idea, like a hedgehog curling into a ball for defense. They identify the intersection of three circles. The first is what they are deeply passionate about. The second is what they can be the best in the world at. The third is what drives their economic engine. Companies that discipline themselves to focus only on this intersection achieve sustained greatness. Walgreens is an example. Its Hedgehog Concept was about being the most convenient drugstore, which guided everything from store locations to product mix.
A Culture of Discipline
Great companies combine entrepreneurial energy with discipline. They empower people with freedom within a framework. Because they hire disciplined people who are aligned with the company’s values, they need fewer rules and bureaucracies. Discipline allows them to act consistently and stay focused on their Hedgehog Concept.
Technology as an Accelerator, Not a Driver
Technology is often mistaken as the source of greatness. Collins found that technology itself does not make companies great. Instead, great companies adopt technology selectively as an accelerator of momentum. They do not chase fads but integrate technology when it amplifies their strategy.
The Flywheel Effect
Transformation does not come from one big decision or dramatic event. It comes from consistent effort that builds momentum like a flywheel. Each push strengthens the wheel until eventually the company achieves a breakthrough. By contrast, companies that fail often lurch from one big initiative to another, never building sustained momentum.
Actionable Insights for Founders and Scale-Up Leaders
Embody Level 5 Leadership
Ask yourself whether your ambition is for personal glory or for the long-term success of the company. Cultivate humility, surround yourself with exceptional leaders, and focus your drive on building something that endures beyond you.
Invest in people before strategy
When planning your next stage of growth, prioritise hiring and retaining the right people over finding the perfect strategy. Build a leadership team that can handle complexity and adapt. Remove those who cannot rise to the level required for the company’s future.
Create a culture of truth-telling
Design rituals and structures that encourage people to share bad news and challenges openly. Celebrate honesty, even when it is uncomfortable. Model this by admitting mistakes yourself and confronting reality directly.
Clarify your Hedgehog Concept
Dedicate time to define your company’s Hedgehog Concept. Ask what you are deeply passionate about, what you can be the best at, and what drives your economic engine. Use this concept as a filter for all strategic decisions.
Build discipline into your culture
Empower people with freedom within a framework. Set clear priorities and values, then allow people to make decisions within those boundaries. Avoid bureaucracy, but insist on accountability and alignment.
Adopt technology with purpose
Do not chase the latest technology trends unless they align with your Hedgehog Concept. Instead, adopt tools and systems that accelerate what you already know works.
Push the flywheel with consistency
Focus on small, consistent wins rather than chasing breakthroughs. Build momentum step by step. Align your organisation around steady progress rather than dramatic gestures.
Practical Checklist Inspired by the Book
1Reflect on your leadership. Are you demonstrating humility while showing relentless commitment to the company’s success?
2Audit your leadership team and identify whether you have the right people on the bus and the wrong people off.
3Host a session with your team to openly confront the brutal facts of your current situation. Document the realities you need to face.
4Work through the Hedgehog Concept by mapping passion, capability, and economic engine. Define the intersection clearly.
5Identify one area where your culture is drifting toward bureaucracy and replace it with frameworks that empower disciplined action.
6Review your technology investments and remove any that are distractions from your core strategy.
7Identify three small but consistent actions that will push your company’s flywheel forward this quarter.
Conclusion
Good to Great is not about flashy moves or heroic leaders. It is about discipline, focus, and humility. Collins shows that greatness comes not from luck or charisma but from consistent effort, the right people, and clarity of purpose.
For scale-up leaders, this book offers grounding wisdom. Hypergrowth can be intoxicating, but the companies that endure are those that build disciplined cultures, confront reality honestly, and focus relentlessly on what they can do best. The lessons are as relevant to a founder leading a company of fifty as they are to a CEO of a multinational enterprise.
The enduring message is that greatness is not an accident. It is the product of deliberate choices, disciplined people, and leadership that channels ambition into building something that lasts.
For scale-up leaders, this book offers grounding wisdom. Hypergrowth can be intoxicating, but the companies that endure are those that build disciplined cultures, confront reality honestly, and focus relentlessly on what they can do best. The lessons are as relevant to a founder leading a company of fifty as they are to a CEO of a multinational enterprise.
The enduring message is that greatness is not an accident. It is the product of deliberate choices, disciplined people, and leadership that channels ambition into building something that lasts.
Apply These Insights
Explore related content to implement what you've learned
Playbooks
Related Reading