Loading page...
Culture
The Five Dysfunctions of a Team
by Patrick Lencioni
Essential Reading for Scale-Up Leaders
A comprehensive review with actionable insights, key takeaways, and practical frameworks for scaling your business.
Why This Book Matters for Scale-Up Leaders
At the scale-up stage, leadership teams carry immense weight. They set direction, make high-stakes decisions, and model culture for the entire company. Yet many leadership teams struggle with hidden dysfunctions that prevent them from performing at their best. Patrick Lencioni’s The Five Dysfunctions of a Team uses a simple fable and clear framework to expose these common pitfalls.
The book matters for scale-up leaders because fast growth magnifies team weaknesses. Misalignment, mistrust, or poor communication at the leadership level cascades through the company. Conversely, a healthy leadership team creates cohesion, clarity, and momentum. Lencioni’s framework gives leaders practical tools to diagnose dysfunction and build high-performing teams.
The book matters for scale-up leaders because fast growth magnifies team weaknesses. Misalignment, mistrust, or poor communication at the leadership level cascades through the company. Conversely, a healthy leadership team creates cohesion, clarity, and momentum. Lencioni’s framework gives leaders practical tools to diagnose dysfunction and build high-performing teams.
Key Insights
Dysfunction One: Absence of Trust
The foundation of every strong team is trust. Without trust, team members hide weaknesses, avoid asking for help, and conceal mistakes. This creates guarded interactions where collaboration never reaches its potential. Trust in this context is not about predictability. It is about vulnerability. Team members must feel safe to admit mistakes, acknowledge weaknesses, and be honest without fear of judgment.
Dysfunction Two: Fear of Conflict
When trust is absent, teams avoid healthy conflict. They prefer artificial harmony, which leads to unresolved tensions and weak decisions. Healthy conflict is about debating ideas passionately without fear of damaging relationships. Teams that embrace conflict arrive at stronger, more committed decisions.
Dysfunction Three: Lack of Commitment
If people do not feel heard during discussions, they are less likely to commit to the final decision. Commitment does not require consensus. It requires clarity and buy-in. Teams that engage in healthy conflict are more likely to achieve true commitment, because everyone has had their voice heard.
Dysfunction Four: Avoidance of Accountability
Without commitment, accountability breaks down. Team members hesitate to hold one another responsible for behaviours or results. High-performing teams embrace peer-to-peer accountability rather than leaving it solely to the leader.
Dysfunction Five: Inattention to Results
The ultimate dysfunction occurs when individuals prioritise personal success, departmental goals, or ego over collective results. Great teams focus on shared goals and measure success by collective achievement.
Actionable Insights for Founders and Scale-Up Leaders
Build vulnerability-based trust
Model vulnerability as a leader. Admit mistakes, ask for help, and share personal challenges. Encourage your team to do the same. Trust grows when leaders demonstrate it first.
Encourage healthy conflict
Redefine conflict as positive. Create safe spaces for debate. Reward people for raising tough issues and challenging assumptions. Ensure conflict is focused on ideas, not personalities.
Create clarity to drive commitment
After discussions, summarise the decision clearly and ensure everyone understands it. Commitment grows when people feel their voices were heard and the decision is unambiguous.
Foster peer-to-peer accountability
Encourage team members to hold one another accountable rather than relying only on you as the leader. Publicly reinforce when accountability is embraced and intervene quickly when it is absent.
Focus relentlessly on collective results
Align incentives and recognition with team success rather than individual achievement. Reinforce the message that the leadership team succeeds or fails together.
Practical Checklist Inspired by the Book
1Begin leadership meetings with a short personal check-in to build vulnerability-based trust.
2Run a team workshop to explicitly define healthy conflict and practice debating tough issues constructively.
3At the end of each meeting, clarify and document decisions so there is no ambiguity about what was agreed.
4Establish norms where team members provide feedback directly to one another, not only through the CEO.
5Set a small number of collective goals for the leadership team and track progress together.
6Regularly celebrate team-level achievements to reinforce focus on shared results.
Conclusion
The Five Dysfunctions of a Team is deceptively simple but profoundly impactful. It shows that the health of a leadership team is built on trust, conflict, commitment, accountability, and results. When even one of these foundations is weak, performance suffers.
For scale-up leaders, the lesson is clear. Your leadership team must model the culture you want across the company. If trust, openness, and accountability are absent at the top, they will be absent everywhere. If they are strong at the top, they will cascade throughout the organisation.
The enduring message is that building a cohesive team is not about removing conflict or pleasing everyone. It is about fostering vulnerability, encouraging debate, aligning on clear decisions, holding one another accountable, and focusing on results above all.
For scale-up leaders, the lesson is clear. Your leadership team must model the culture you want across the company. If trust, openness, and accountability are absent at the top, they will be absent everywhere. If they are strong at the top, they will cascade throughout the organisation.
The enduring message is that building a cohesive team is not about removing conflict or pleasing everyone. It is about fostering vulnerability, encouraging debate, aligning on clear decisions, holding one another accountable, and focusing on results above all.
Apply These Insights
Explore related content to implement what you've learned
Related Reading